Local comparisonIllustrative evidence

Central Valley: a nearby merger with no simple success story

Ilion and Mohawk became Central Valley in 2013. Herkimer participated in the merger discussion but remained independent, making it a useful comparison with clear limits.

Plain-language takeaway

What this case tells us

Central Valley’s experience does not show that a merger automatically lowers tax growth, slows enrollment loss, or improves student performance.

That is a reason to ask for specific, testable Cazenovia–Morrisville-Eaton projections. It is not proof that every merger will have the same result.

Tax levy

Recent levy changes were similar

The original CFP site compared Central Valley with Herkimer. Official 2026–27 budget pages confirm the latest figures shown here.

Annual change in total tax levy

Budget years 2023–24 through 2026–27

Central ValleyHerkimer
Annual tax levy change for Central Valley and HerkimerCentral Valley: 0.92, 0, 3.4, and 2.09 percent. Herkimer: 0, 1.75, 1.75, and 1.98 percent. 0%1%2%3%4% 2023–242024–252025–262026–27
View the chart data
Budget yearCentral ValleyHerkimer
2023–240.92%0.00%
2024–250.00%1.75%
2025–263.40%1.75%
2026–272.09%1.98%

Read carefully: a levy is the total amount raised by property tax. It is not the same as an individual tax bill or a tax rate. Four recent years cannot establish what caused the changes. Sources: district budget pages and the CFP Merger Truth comparison.

What the four-year figures show

Compounded over these four changes, Central Valley’s total levy grew about 6.5% and Herkimer’s about 5.6%. The difference is small, and the chart does not show each district’s starting levy, property values, state aid, services, or reserves. It does show that a past merger did not produce an obvious recent tax-growth advantage.

Enrollment

Both districts lost students

The original site reports NYSED enrollment for 2013–14 and 2024–25. Central Valley’s percentage decline was larger.

−17.1%

Central Valley

2,309 students in 2013–14 to 1,914 in 2024–25, a decline of 395 students.

−10.6%

Herkimer

1,146 students in 2013–14 to 1,025 in 2024–25, a decline of 121 students.

11 yrs

Comparison period

The figures describe what happened. They do not show why families enrolled, moved, or chose other schools.

Student results

The ELA comparison is mixed

The original site compiled NYSED report-card results for Grade 4, Grade 8, and Regents ELA. These comparisons should be treated as descriptive.

Grade 4

Central Valley often compared favorably with Herkimer. The original analysis notes that the elementary schools were not combined, which makes this a weak test of school consolidation.

Grade 8

Herkimer scored higher in 6 of 11 post-merger years. Central Valley scored higher in the other five years. This does not show a consistent merged-district advantage.

Regents ELA

Results varied by year. Herkimer had trailed both predecessor districts in the six pre-merger comparisons reported by the original site, then was closer to Central Valley afterward.

Why we stop short of a causal claim

Test difficulty, participation, cohort size, student needs, staffing, leadership, and pandemic disruption can change year to year. A simple district comparison cannot prove that the merger caused the pattern. The fair conclusion is narrower: the public data does not show a clear, durable academic boost that can confidently be attributed to the merger.

Relevance here

Questions for the Cazenovia–Morrisville-Eaton plan

  • Which savings are contractual and measurable, beyond eliminating one superintendent?
  • Which programs will be added, how many students will use them, and what do they cost after incentive aid?
  • What enrollment assumptions are used, and how sensitive is the plan if enrollment falls faster?
  • Which buildings and grade arrangements remain in place, and for how long?

See the neighboring OESJ comparison.

Its latest budget adds an important update to the data published on the original site.

Next case: OESJ