Local comparisonIllustrative evidence

OESJ: another nearby merger with mixed results

Oppenheim-Ephratah and St. Johnsville formed one district for the 2013–14 school year. Canajoharie and Fort Plain provide nearby context, while the newest OESJ budget shows why every comparison needs regular updates.

Plain-language takeaway

What this case tells us

Through 2025–26, OESJ’s levy grew faster than the two nearby comparison districts, and the ELA record did not show a consistent academic advantage.

For 2026–27, OESJ approved a zero levy increase. That update matters. The fair reading is that merger outcomes move over time and should be judged against clear promises, not a single favorable or unfavorable year.

Tax levy

Four years of higher cumulative growth

The total tax levy is the amount a district raises from local property taxes. It is different from a household’s tax bill or the tax rate.

Annual change in total tax levy

Budget years 2022–23 through 2025–26

OESJCanajoharieFort Plain
Annual tax levy change for OESJ, Canajoharie, and Fort PlainFrom 2022–23 through 2025–26, OESJ changed 1.98, 2.98, 2.98, and 2.98 percent. Canajoharie changed 2.90, 1.64, 2.57, and 1.53 percent. Fort Plain changed 1.44, 1.20, 1.43, and 1.00 percent. 0%1%2%3% 2022–232023–242024–252025–26
View the chart data
Budget yearOESJCanajoharieFort Plain
2022–231.98%2.90%1.44%
2023–242.98%1.64%1.20%
2024–252.98%2.57%1.43%
2025–262.98%1.53%1.00%

Read carefully: these are annual changes, so the correct four-year comparison is compounded. The figures do not control for starting budgets, property values, services, reserves, enrollment, or state aid.

11.37%

OESJ

Compounded levy growth across the four annual changes shown above.

8.92%

Canajoharie

Compounded levy growth across the same four budget years.

5.17%

Fort Plain

Compounded levy growth across the same four budget years.

Current update: OESJ approved a 0% levy increase for 2026–27

OESJ’s official budget notice reports a $24.5 million budget, a 2.85% spending increase, and no increase in the tax levy. That year is kept separate because comparable final 2026–27 figures were not consistently available for all three districts when this page was reviewed.

Student results

Nearby districts often had the higher ELA result

The original site counted which district had the higher result in 11 post-merger years. This is an easy summary to read, but it leaves out the size of each difference.

Grade 4 ELA

Canajoharie was higher in 7 of 11 years; Fort Plain was higher in 6 of 11. Different elementary configurations and small groups limit what this says about merger effects.

Grade 8 ELA

Canajoharie was higher in 10 of 11 years; Fort Plain in 8 of 11. The pattern does not support a claim of a consistent OESJ advantage.

Regents ELA

Canajoharie was higher in 9 of 11 years; Fort Plain in 6 of 11. A year-by-year count describes the record; it cannot tell us what caused it.

Why this is descriptive evidence

Small cohorts can move percentages sharply. Student needs, test participation, curriculum, leadership, staffing, and pandemic disruptions also changed during the period. Score scales and reporting rules should be checked before comparing long time spans. The defensible conclusion is that the public results do not show a clear, durable OESJ academic advantage.

Relevance here

Questions this case raises

A local example can sharpen the questions even when it cannot predict the answer.

  • What exact tax-levy path is projected for each community, year by year?
  • What happens when temporary merger aid declines?
  • Which academic outcomes will be tracked, and what result counts as success?
  • Will reports show both district-wide averages and results for each building and student group?

Follow the money beyond one budget year.

The next case reviews New York merger spending before and after reorganization.

Next: New York finance